Determining Whether to Offer Multiple Health Plan Options

When it comes to employee benefits, healthcare coverage is often considered one of the most crucial. Providing employees access to quality health care can help keep them healthy and happy, increasing productivity and reducing turnover rates. Employers can ensure their employees have access to the best possible care by offering multiple health plan options. However, determining whether to offer multiple plans can be a complex decision that requires careful consideration of various factors.

Budget Constraints and Workforce Composition

Budget is an essential consideration for employers when determining the number and types of plans they can offer. Providing health insurance coverage can be expensive, and employers with smaller budgets may need to scale back their health plan options to fit their needs best. One way to do this is by offering a single health plan option that provides adequate coverage for most employees. However, larger employers may have more resources to invest in multiple plans that offer varying levels of coverage.

Workforce composition also plays a significant role in determining the types of health plan options that should be offered. For example, an employer with a workforce of similar age and medical disposition may only need one offer. In contrast, an employer with a diverse range of ages and medical needs may consider having multiple plans. Employers can gather data on their workforce composition through employee surveys, medical claims data, and other sources to help inform their decision-making.

Range of Coverage Needed

Employers should also consider the range of coverage that most of their employees need when deciding whether to offer multiple health plan options. Employers can gather data on their employees' health needs through employee surveys, medical claims data, and other sources to help inform their decision-making.

For some employers, a single plan may provide adequate coverage for most employees. However, other employers may find that an extensive range of coverage is needed, particularly if they have employees with unique health needs. In these cases, it may be best to offer multiple plan options to ensure that all employees have access to the care they need.

Employers can also assess the range of coverage that most of their employees need when deciding whether to offer multiple plans. For some employers, an extensive range of coverage may be needed, and it may be best to have multiple plans. For example, an employer in the construction industry may have employees at higher risk of injury and require more comprehensive coverage than employees in other industries. An option for employers who offer fewer options is to offer at least one choice with varying levels of coverage, allowing employees to select the plan that best meets their individual needs.

Types of Health Plan Options Available

When considering which health plan options to offer, employers should be familiar with the different types of plans available, including Health insurance organization (HMO) plans, Preferred provider organization (PPO) plans, Exclusive provider organization (EPO) plans, High deductible health plans (HDHP), and Point-of-service (POS) plans. Each type of plan has its own pros and cons, and employers should carefully consider which plans best meet the needs of their employees.

Types of Health Plans:

Health insurance organization (HMO) plans - An HMO plan often has low premiums, deductibles, and fixed copays for doctor visits. While less expensive, HMO plans require employees to seek care from only in-network providers. When signing up for the plan, employees select a primary care physician (PCP) for routine checkups. The PCP must give a referral before patients can see a specialist, such as an allergist or dermatologist.

Preferred provider organization (PPO) plans - PPO plans have pricier premiums than HMO plans, but they allow employees to see specialists and out-of-network providers without referrals. Out-of-network care typically involves greater employee cost sharing, but in-network copays and coinsurance are generally low. More paperwork is typically involved with out-of-network providers.

Exclusive provider organization (EPO) plans - An EPO plan offers moderate freedom to employees to choose their health care providers. Like HMO plans, EPO plans only cover in-network care; however, they typically don’t require specialist referrals from PCPs. Premiums are generally higher than those of HMO plans but lower than PPO plans’ premiums.

High deductible health plans (HDHP) - have low premiums but higher immediate out-of-pocket costs. An HDHP is often paired with a health savings account (HSA), a tax-advantaged account used to pay for qualified medical expenses. An advantage of an HSA is that the remaining funds at the plan year's end can roll over into the account for the following year.

Point-of-service (POS) plans - A POS plan combines an HMO and PPO plan. Such a plan allows employees to choose whether to use HMO or PPO services each time they receive health care. For slightly higher premiums than an HMO plan, a POS plan can cover out-of-network doctors. As such, it’ll be more beneficial and cost-effective if an employee initially sees a PCP and seeks in-network care rather than not seeing a PCP for a referral first.

Balancing Employee Needs with Budget Constraints

Health plan options are an essential part of an employee benefits package, and employers should strive to offer plans that employees find beneficial. Employers can help ensure their employees can access the care they need by providing multiple health plan options. However, employers should balance their desire to provide employees with various options with their budgetary constraints.

Ultimately, whether to offer multiple health plan options will depend on each organization's unique needs and circumstances. For additional information or questions, employers can consult with an insurance provider or a benefits expert at Get-Benefits. 

With questions or additional information, please get in touch with us today.